Site icon Breaking Views – Rajdeep Sardesai

Scotch On The Rocks

It appears that the nay-sayers have won the Scotland referendum: Scotland will remain a part of  Great Britain after a long and contentious debate. There is no place in the world quite as pretty as the Scottish countryside. As a college student in Britain, my best holiday was to the Scottish isles: golf, long walks, and yes, a touch of Scotch! Scotland is distinctive: the accent has a lush tone to it, the kilts and the bagpipes are unique and the pubs in Edinburgh remain open till  way beyond closing time in London (and, oh yes, the original James Bond, Sean Connery is a proud Scot). I can see why England doesn’t want to lose its lovely Scottish corner: it just offers Great Britain a more rich and plural heritage. I can also see why several Scots don’t want to be part of  Britain: Scottish nationalism provides a badge of  identity.  

But while Scotland will stay within Britain and enrich the country, the referendum does reflect the need for a healing touch. Several parts of  Scotland wanted independence, others did not. Scottish society appears more divided than ever before. And yet, what is heartening is to see a society and its politicians accept the final result with grace and dignity. I was watching the unfolding of  the results on BBC: not once did I see noisy recrimination or the blame game which is typical of  Indian politics. British democracy was resilient enough to face a referendum and emerge stronger as a result of  it. The political class of  that country deserves two cheers for it. The third I have reserved for the television anchors. Right through the voting, the reportage and analysis was devoid of  needless noise. Sitting in Delhi, I actually got a sense of  what was happening on the ground. Clearly, there is still some space left for intelligent television!

Exit mobile version